Civil & criminal appeals · Boston, Massachusetts

The right argument, clearly made.

Alexandra H. Deal has spent more than fifteen years briefing and arguing appeals in the Massachusetts Appeals Court, the Supreme Judicial Court and the First Circuit. She finds the issues that matter and writes the briefs that make judges see them.

  • 20+years as a civil and criminal litigator
  • 15+years of appellate practice
Portrait of attorney Alexandra H. Deal
Alexandra H. Deal Appellate attorney · Partner, Paik Deal LLP
About Alex

An appellate lawyer from the very first day.

“There is nothing I love more than researching an issue in depth and coming up with a great argument to support my client’s position.” Alexandra H. Deal

Alex began her legal career as an appellate law clerk at the D.C. Court of Appeals, and quickly fell in love with appellate practice. Two decades later, she has built a career on both sides of the trial-and-appeal divide: more than 20 years as a civil and criminal litigator, and more than 15 years handling appeals in both.

That trial experience is what sets her appellate work apart. She knows how records get made, where error hides in a transcript, and how a strong argument at trial becomes a winning issue on appeal.

Her writing is crisp, unfussy and approachable: think law nerd minus the legal jargon, storyteller minus the unnecessary adjectives. Judges read a lot of briefs. Hers are built to be read, understood and remembered.

Why hire Alex

What you get with an appellate lawyer who has also tried cases.

01

Deep, careful research

Appeals turn on the law. Alex runs every issue to ground, from the controlling precedent to the case nobody else found, and builds the argument from there.

02

Briefs that read clearly

Plain, persuasive writing that tells your client’s story without the jargon. Clear briefs are easier for busy judges to follow, and easier to agree with.

03

Proven in the courtroom

She has briefed, argued and won in the Massachusetts Appeals Court, the Supreme Judicial Court and the First Circuit, and has served as co-counsel in the D.C. Circuit.

04

Trusted by other appellate lawyers

As a Resource Attorney for the Committee for Public Counsel Services, Alex guides other appellate attorneys on issue-spotting, brief writing and oral argument.

Services

Three ways Alex can help.

Whether you are a client facing an appeal or a trial lawyer who wants an experienced appellate lawyer’s eye on your case, there is a way to work together.

Appellate counsel

Full representation on appeal in criminal and civil cases, from reviewing the record through the final brief and oral argument.

  • Record review and issue selection
  • Briefs, reply briefs and motions
  • Oral argument
  • Further appellate review applications

Ghostwriting

For trial counsel who want to see a case through to the end, but would rather hand off the research and writing. Alex drafts the briefs and motions; you stay counsel of record.

  • Research memos and issue analysis
  • Drafting principal and reply briefs
  • Argument preparation and moots

Trial co-counsel

Help at the pre-trial and trial stages to set the case up for appeal, if it comes to that. (Alex believes in your trial skills!)

  • Identifying and preserving appellate issues
  • Motions in limine
  • Trial motions
  • Post-trial motions
Approach

Every case is a puzzle.

Alex approaches cases holistically, as puzzles whose pieces must fit together into a complete strategic and factual picture, always with an eye toward identifying and preserving appellate issues along the way.

  1. Master the recordEvery transcript, exhibit and ruling, read closely, because the issues that win appeals are often buried there.
  2. Choose the right issuesNot every error is worth raising. Alex picks the arguments with the best chance of success and builds the brief around them.
  3. Tell a clear storyA brief that reads like a well-crafted narrative, not a stack of citations, so the court understands why your client should win.
  4. Argue it with confidenceOral argument prepared to the last question, with the record and the law at hand.
Credentials

Education, recognition and admissions.

Education

  • Boston College Law SchoolJ.D., cum laude, 2004
  • Cornell UniversityB.A., with distinction, 2000

Recognition

  • Massachusetts Super LawyersSuper Lawyer, 2019–2026
  • Massachusetts Super LawyersRising Star, 2009–2018
  • Boston MagazineTop Lawyer, Civil Litigation, 2021

Admissions

  • Commonwealth of Massachusetts
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
  • U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts
  • Mashpee Wampanoag Tribal Court
Contact

Have an appeal, or a trial that might become one?

Appellate deadlines are short. Reach out early, whether you are a client, a family member or trial counsel looking for help.

Telephone 339-227-0812 Email adeal@paikdeal.com
Office 6 Beacon Street, Suite 815
Boston, MA 02108

Please don’t send confidential information until we have confirmed that we can take your matter. Contacting Alex does not create an attorney-client relationship.